The Fall Problem You Didn’t See Coming
As we head into fall in Seattle, there’s a beautiful transformation across our neighborhoods—trees burst into color, and leaves begin to blanket the ground. But with that beauty comes a persistent landscape issue that’s often overlooked during the design phase.
Gravel under trees.
Last year, I was walking to my favorite coffee shop in South Park and snapped this photo (see above). What you’re seeing is the result of a common design choice that, while it may look clean and modern at first, quickly becomes a maintenance nightmare—especially here in the Pacific Northwest.
One of the Most Common Landscape Design Mistakes: Hard-to-Maintain Spaces
There’s a big difference between designing for visual appeal on installation day and designing for how a landscape will function and evolve over time.
One of the most common issues we see? Designers specifying materials or layouts that are beautiful—but totally impractical for Seattle’s climate and maintenance realities. Gravel under tree canopies is a perfect example.
Why Gravel Under Trees Doesn’t Work in Seattle
🍂 1. Leaf Drop Turns Gravel into a Debris Trap
Seattle’s tree canopy is dense—and whether it’s your tree or your neighbor’s, organic matter is going to fall. Leaves, pine needles, twigs, seed pods—you name it.
Gravel doesn’t absorb or break down this debris. Instead, it just accumulates on top, making the area look messy and quickly negating that clean aesthetic.
🌱 2. It Creates the Perfect Habitat for Weeds
Over time, that buildup of organic material acts like compost, giving weed seeds a perfect place to germinate. These weeds are notoriously hard to remove from gravel, where roots anchor deep between the rocks.
The result: a patchy, overgrown area that’s time-consuming and frustrating to maintain.
⚠️ 3. Gravel Under Trees Encourages Harmful Maintenance Practices
Frustrated by the constant weeding without getting to the root (pun intended) of the problem, many property owners end up resorting to chemical herbicides, which:
- Damage surrounding tree roots and soil life
- Harm pollinators and beneficial insects
- Contaminate stormwater and local ecosystems
This approach undermines the goals of sustainable landscaping and can be difficult to reverse once the cycle begins. It is easier to make a poor decision if the correct decision is difficult – make it easier to make the sustainable choices you believe in!
Better Options for Tree Understories
Instead of gravel, consider solutions that work with Seattle’s natural environment—not against it.
✅ Use Organic Mulch
- Suppresses weeds
- Improves soil health
- Breaks down naturally with the leaf litter
✅ Install Shade-Tolerant Plants
Great options for Seattle include:
- Sword ferns
- Salal
- Kinnikinnick
- Sarcococca
- Hostas
- Evergreen huckleberry (for larger or sloped areas)
These create lush, resilient understory layers that require less effort to maintain and support local biodiversity.
Why Design-Build Firms Avoid These Mistakes
At Seattle Sustainable Landscapes, we do both design and installation, and we also maintain many of the landscapes we build. That means we’re constantly thinking about:
- How spaces age and change
- Who will maintain them
- What materials are appropriate for long-term use
- How the homeowner will use the space
Because we live with the consequences of our design choices, we avoid the kinds of impractical decisions—like gravel under a mature tree—that may look good on a rendering but don’t work in real life. Gravel under trees is just one example of how design should be informed by real-world experiences.
Final Thought: Design for the Seasons, Not Just the Snapshot
A landscape isn’t static—it changes through the seasons and over the years. What works in summer may fall apart in autumn. And what looks sharp on install day may become a burden by year three.
If your current landscape includes hard-to-maintain features or you’re thinking about a new design, we’d love to help create something that’s beautiful, functional, and aligned with Seattle’s climate and your lifestyle.
Click here to go back to our Blog Page
Click here to go back to our company Home Page
Contact Us for more information!